Latepost The Crude Oil Cost Shock: Primary, Secondary In Addition To Collateral Effects

In the final few weeks, fiscal markets withdraw maintain been rocked past times the driblet inwards crude oil prices, in addition to inwards the procedure reminded us of 3 realities. The offset is that for all the coin that is spent on commodity cost forecasting, in that location is real lilliputian that nosotros withdraw maintain to demo for it. The 2nd is that all large macroeconomic events create winners in addition to losers in addition to the internet lawsuit of this crude oil cost change, whether positive, neutral or negative, may accept a piece to manifest itself. The 3rd is that investors are to a greater extent than ofttimes than non ill-served past times either panicky selling of all things oil-related or the mindless buying of the most beaten-up crude oil stocks.

Oil: Prices driblet in addition to doubtfulness climbs

At the start of 2014, the cost per barrel of Brent unsmooth crude oil was to a greater extent than or less $108/barrel, next 3 years of prices higher than $100/barrel. In fact, in that location seemed to hold out lilliputian argue to believe, given signs of economical recovery inwards the United States, that crude oil prices would driblet whatever fourth dimension soon. H5N1 combination of mild need shocks (with reduced need from China) in addition to to a greater extent than noticeable furnish shocks conspired to create the cost drop, starting inwards September, accompanied past times to a greater extent than doubtfulness nigh hereafter prices:

While much of the attending has been directed at the 40% driblet inwards crude oil prices, the tripling inwards implied volatility inwards crude oil prices is a worth paying attending to in addition to every bit I volition fighting later, could withdraw maintain an lawsuit on non only crude oil stocks but on the overall market.

The initial stories nigh the crude oil cost daze were almost all positive, suggesting that lower gas prices would allow consumers to pass to a greater extent than coin on retail, restaurants in addition to other businesses, thus boosting the economy. In the offset 2 weeks of December, though, in that location was an sudden shift inwards mood, every bit the same journalists who were lauding the crude oil cost driblet a few weeks agone were pointing their fingers at it every bit the primary culprit behind worldwide stock cost declines inwards those weeks.

The Clueless Trifecta: Forecasters, Companies in addition to Investors

The most sobering aspect of the crude oil cost collapse is that is genuinely came out of nowhere, amongst none of the economical forecasters at the start of 2014 predicting the magnitude of the drop. In early on 2014, Bloomberg's survey of the "most accurate" crude oil cost forecasters yielded a forecast of $105 for crude oil prices for the year, illustrating that "accurate" is a relative term inwards this market. In a Reuter's poll inwards Dec 2013, which surveyed analysts nigh crude oil prices inwards 2014, the lowest cost forecast was $75 past times Ed Morse, Gobal Head of Commodities Research at Citibank in addition to a longtime conduct on crude oil prices. 

If yous believe that crude oil companies, existence closer to the action, were prescient, yous would hold out wrong. Early inwards 2014, Chevron announced that its budgeting would hold out based upon crude oil prices of $110/barrel, amongst John Watson, the company’s CEO, stating, “There is a novel reality inwards our business… $100/bbl is becoming the novel $20/bbl inwards our business… costs withdraw maintain caught upwards to revenues for many classes of projects.” in addition to adding that, “If $100 is the novel $20, consumers volition pay to a greater extent than for oil.” Chevron was non lonely inwards this assessment in addition to crude oil companies globally made investment, acquisition in addition to production decisions based upon the supposition that triple-digit crude oil prices were hither to stay, which explains why at a $60 crude oil cost or lower, almost a trillion dollars inwards investments made past times crude oil companies were no longer viable. Looking at airlines, where fuel costs stand upwards for a large proportion of operating expenses, in that location is evidence that fuel hedging follows the crude oil price, rather than leading it. Fuel hedging peaked inwards 2008, only every bit crude oil prices peaked, in addition to withdraw maintain tracked crude oil prices downwardly inwards the years since. 

Completing the clueless trifecta, investors withdraw maintain also been behind the bend on crude oil prices.  Institutional coin continued to period of time into crude oil stocks for most of the yr in addition to flowed out alone inwards the final quarter every bit crude oil stocks tumbled.  The so-called smart coin did worse, amongst hedge funds amid the biggest losers inwards crude oil stocks, amongst articles/oils-drop-hits-big-investors-hard-1418950116">big names similar Icahn in addition to Paulson leading the agency amongst large money-losing bets. If in that location is whatever practiced tidings for crude oil cost bulls, it is that crude oil forecasters are right away predicting lower crude oil prices side past times side year, crude oil companies are reassessing their assumptions nigh a normal crude oil price, airlines are reducing or fifty-fifty suspending their hedging in addition to institutional investors are fleeing from crude oil stocks. Given their collective runway record, this may hold out the best fourth dimension to bet on ascent crude oil prices.

The Biggest Losers

When crude oil prices drop, the most immediate impact is on crude oil producers in addition to the ecosystem that serves them, including equipment in addition to service providers. Within this group, though, the lawsuit tin vary depending on geography, size in addition to leverage, every bit nosotros volition consider inwards the nest section.

a. Companies inwards the crude oil business
The lawsuit of an crude oil cost alter on a crude oil producing society may seem obvious, but it goes beyond the lawsuit on revenues in addition to earnings inwards the close term. By changing the wages to growth in addition to the withdraw a chance inwards the company, a alter inwards crude oil cost tin withdraw maintain a multiplier lawsuit on value.

With these effects inwards place, yous should await the most negative effects of declining crude oil prices to hold out at highly levered crude oil companies amongst costlier reserves in addition to higher fixed costs. 

Let’s facial expression at the numbers. In the final 3 months, every bit crude oil prices withdraw maintain dropped, crude oil society stocks withdraw maintain taken a pummeling, losing a jaw-dropping $1.7 trillion inwards marketplace capitalization, every bit evidenced inwards the tabular array below, amongst companies broken downwardly into unlike sub-businesses:

Source: S&P Capital IQ

Note that the companies at the production in addition to drilling terminate of the crude oil cycle withdraw maintain been wound the most past times lower prices, piece the companies that withdraw maintain been wound the to the lowest degree are at refining in addition to distribution end. Within the crude oil business, the harm also varies across companies. Breaking the numbers downwardly further, hither is what nosotros see:

Smaller, lower-rated companies withdraw maintain been striking harder than larger, investment-grade companies, amongst the carnage existence greatest for Latin American companies. In the alone surprising (at to the lowest degree to me) finding, firms amongst the highest turn a profit margins (in terms of EBITDA/Sales) withdraw maintain seen bigger losses inwards marketplace value than firms amongst lower margins.  (Update: My offset idea on this was that firms amongst higher EBITDA/Sales mightiness withdraw maintain higher debt ratios and that the debt lawsuit was overwhelming the profitability effect. The tabular array below gives partial support, since it is among the most highly levered firms that you consider the high profitability/negative render human relationship to hold out stronger, but in that location is something else also happening inwards the background. So, dorsum to the grind..)

Simple averages of 3-month returns across stocks

Note that I was using this mensurate of profitability every bit a unsmooth proxy for the cost of reserves owned past times companies, since yous should await companies amongst higher cost reserves to hold out wound to a greater extent than past times lower crude oil prices than those amongst lower cost reserves. As higher crude oil prices withdraw maintain induced companies to explore for in addition to educate novel reserves, the cost of extracting crude oil is much higher at some of the newer reserves, every bit this chart for only shale crude oil reserves inwards the US indicates:

Source: 

I would accept the breakeven prices that analysts study for reserves amongst a  grain of salt, because computing a truthful breakeven would bespeak significantly to a greater extent than information nigh sunk versus incremental every bit good every bit fixed versus variable costs of production than nosotros withdraw maintain access to, but the fundamental truth remains. As crude oil prices drop, the lawsuit on value in addition to viability volition vary across reserves in addition to that lawsuit should in addition to so percolate through to companies.

b. Oil Exporting Countries
Moving from companies to countries, it is clear that the companies that lose the most from lower crude oil prices are the large crude oil exporters. Among those countries, though, the effects volition vary (as they did amongst companies), based upon the cost of extracting crude oil from the reserves, how much sovereign debt is owed past times the province in addition to how subject they are on crude oil revenues to repose their books. Countries amongst higher-cost reserves that are to a greater extent than subject on crude oil revenues to encounter debt obligations/balance books should hold out to a greater extent than negatively affected past times crude oil cost changes, in addition to the tabular array below provides these statistics:

Between September xvi in addition to Dec 16, every bit crude oil prices retreated, the most vulnerable province (partly because of its dependence on crude oil for revenues in addition to partly because of geopolitical events) has been Russia. In the graph below, nosotros capture the carnage inwards changes inwards the sovereign CDS spread for Russian Federation (a mensurate of default withdraw a chance inwards the country) in addition to inwards the Russian Ruble.

Looking to a greater extent than broadly, it is clear that the harm is non express to Russia, every bit evidenced inwards this graph of sovereign CDS spreads for iv crude oil exporting countries: Russia, Venezuela, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in addition to United Mexican States (with the September xvi CDS cost existence laid at 100 for all four).

The harm has been greatest inwards Russian Federation in addition to Venezuela, amongst the Russian CDS increasing 137.83%  and the Venezuelan CDS to a greater extent than than tripling. However,  Saudi Arabia in addition to Mexico, though inwards much improve shape, withdraw maintain also been affected amongst the Mexican CDS increasing nigh 58% in addition to the Saudi CDS increasing 65%.

The Ripple Effects

The harm extends beyond the crude oil trouble concern to light-green unloose energy companies, which withdraw maintain benefited from high crude oil prices inwards the final decade, in addition to lenders to crude oil companies, who experience the effects of increased credit risk. In the tabular array below, I gauge the lawsuit of lower crude oil prices on green/clean unloose energy companies in addition to corporate bonds issued past times unloose energy companies:

As amongst the crude oil sector, the extent of the harm varies across sub-groups, greater for the 10 largest solar companies than it is for companies across the solar unloose energy chain or to a greater extent than broadly inwards construct clean energy. Consistent amongst the conduct of returns across stocks across ratings classes, investment storey unloose energy bonds were much less affected than below investment storey bonds. 

The winners from lower crude oil prices are harder to find, at to the lowest degree inwards the curt term. You would await that companies that withdraw maintain a high proportion of their costs connected to crude oil prices to gain the most, in addition to the 2 sectors that were mentioned every bit beneficiaries were the airlines in addition to trucking companies.

The airlines were the biggest gainers, but notation that the collective marketplace value added (about $55 billion across all companies inwards the sector, globally) was dwarfed past times the losses of to a greater extent than than $2 trillion inwards crude oil in addition to light-green unloose energy companies.

In the long term, the general consensus seems to hold out that lower crude oil prices volition hold out practiced for the economy in addition to perhaps, fifty-fifty for stock prices. Looking at crude oil cost movements in addition to their lawsuit on the economy, inflation in addition to stock prices over the final forty years, hither is what I find:

Correlation betwixt lagging crude oil cost changes & leading macro variables: 1974-2013

Between 1974 in addition to 2013, in that location is lilliputian evidence that lower crude oil prices (in either dollar or percent terms) withdraw maintain had whatever lawsuit on economical growth (real GDP), involvement & inflation rates or stock prices. In fact, the alone variable where in that location is a human relationship is amongst the US dollar, in addition to lower crude oil prices withdraw maintain led to a weakening of the currency historically. Looking at the merchandise off, in that location are 2 key benefits that come upwards from lower crude oil prices. The offset is that consumers volition hold out spending less on crude oil (for transportation in addition to heating) in addition to volition thus withdraw maintain will trim down inflation, at to the lowest degree inwards the close term, thus giving key banks a lilliputian to a greater extent than wiggle room inwards monetary policy. There are, however, 2 potential costs. The offset is that amongst a large plenty crude oil cost drop, the fiscal distress at crude oil companies in addition to crude oil exporting countries may spread into the repose of the economy; defaults past times large crude oil companies or a large sovereign borrower tin create chaos inwards the fiscal markets. The 2nd is that crude oil prices inwards costless autumn are ofttimes accompanied past times higher doubtfulness nigh hereafter crude oil prices, every bit has been the illustration inwards the final few weeks, which, inwards turn, tin Pb to to a greater extent than doubtfulness nigh overall economical growth, involvement rates in addition to inflation. Since these are drivers of the overall equity withdraw a chance premium, a higher equity withdraw a chance premium in addition to lower stock prices volition ensue. It is true, that the crude oil cost driblet inwards the final few weeks, has been large, relative to history, in addition to that the effects may hence hold out different, but that may hold out i to a greater extent than argue non to hold off in addition to consider what the macroeconomic effects of these prices volition be.

What now?

You may non hold out a marketplace timer or crude oil cost forecaster but crude oil prices do withdraw maintain an lawsuit on your portfolio in addition to peradventure on your investment strategy. As yous facial expression at the harm created past times plunging crude oil prices, at to the lowest degree to the crude oil inwards your portfolio, it is slow to 2nd guess decisions that yous made weeks, months or fifty-fifty years ago. I believe that regret in addition to omphalos gazing is non alone pointless but unsafe in addition to that your fourth dimension volition hold out improve spent picking upwards the pieces in addition to looking forward. Generically, in that location are iv viewpoints that yous tin withdraw maintain on crude oil prices: that they volition overstep away on to refuse (the momentum story), that $60 is the novel normal cost ($60 is the novel $100), that they withdraw maintain fallen every bit good far in addition to volition bounce dorsum (the contrarian play) or that whatever of the higher upwards (price agnostic). Within each viewpoint nigh oil, yous tin either become for a protective strategy or an aggressive one, amongst the latter becoming to a greater extent than attractive every bit your confidence inwards your viewpoint increases.

You tin set me firmly inwards the "price agnostic" category. The crude oil cost exposure that I withdraw maintain inwards my portfolios reflects investments that I withdraw maintain made over fourth dimension inwards stocks that I perceived every bit practiced value at the fourth dimension that I made them in addition to were non designed primarily to increment my crude oil cost exposure. If I select to sell them, it volition hold out because I don't sentiment them every bit practiced value, given crude oil prices at the fourth dimension of the assessment, whatever to a greater extent than in addition to non because I withdraw maintain a dot of sentiment on crude oil prices.  Thus, my Lukoil investment from nigh iv weeks ago, when crude oil prices were $77/barrel,  is downwardly nigh 15%, but  given today's crude oil price, it is nether valued today. My investment timing clearly left much to hold out desired but selling it today volition non larn me my coin back!

Attachments:

1. Companies inwards the crude oil sector: Price changes from 9/16/14 to 12/16/14
2. Oil Prices in addition to Macroeconomic Variables
3. Sovereign CDS spreads for crude oil exporters: 9/16/14 to 12/16/16

Tweet

Subscribe to receive free email updates: